Metro » Government & Politics

Cosmopolitan Conservative: Tea Partying, Chattanooga Style

By Adrienne Royer | April 16, 2009, 11:49 a.m.

Editor's Note: This is a guest post by the Cosmopolitan Conservative, a Chattanooga blogger. For more on the history and rationale behind the Tea Party movement, please read What's the Deal With the Tea Parties? on the CosmoCon's blog.


Chattanooga Tea Party 


On an overcast and chilly Wednesday afternoon, more than 1,000 people converged at Ross's Landing to join the Tea Party movement sweeping the nation. Were these people concerned that they may have joined an “astroturfed” event? Doubtful. Were they stereotypical right-wing Evangelicals, toting Bible verses and yielding pro-gun signs? A few (Libertarian Jesus was my favorite). Were they seasoned conservative activists who never miss a chance to stick it to the Left—those crazy pro-lifers that Homeland Security is now carefully monitoring? Probably, I was there after all. However, the overwhelming number of people had never protested a day in their lives. For many, this was the first rally that they had ever attended.



I spent most of the rally wandering around the crowd, talking to people and asking why they were there. The range of ages surprised me. This was not a crowd of angry, old men or fat cats afraid of losing their wealth. Families with very young children, teenagers, young women, Boomers and senior citizens filled the crowd. These were people who were angry at the government’s lack of restraint and free-spending. They weren’t political operatives hell-bent on destroying President Obama but residents of Chattanooga and northern Georgia who are fearful for their children’s futures and desperate to keep their hard-earned dollars in their own pocketbooks. Theresa Place, a sixtyish Chattanooga native, was there with her friends, who were also in their 60s and 70s. None of them had ever attended a protest or rally and proudly exclaimed that they were tired of being part of the Silent Majority. Theresa, the spokeswoman for the group, was angry and showed up at the Tea Party to express it, “We’re tired of out-of-control spending and a change towards socialism. Hard-working people are suffering. Spending is what got us into this, so we’re going to spend, tax and borrow in to the new millennium to fix it?” Her friend, who wished to remain anonymous, was also frustrated and angry with the government,“I’m 74 years-old, and I’ve never protested a day in my life. I’m madder than ‘you know what.’” Another protester, Jeremy Johns was taking advantage of his right to assembly for the first time.“This is my first protest. There have been many issues over the years that have upset me, but this is the first time that I’ve protested.” Holly Long, an Ooltewah resident, showed up with her young children all sporting shirts expressing how much debt they were already in thanks to Uncle Sam: “We want them to be a part of this. Something that hasn’t happened for 300 years. I’m fed up. I’m tired of how expensive my children’s futures are going to be.” Diedre Hall and her kids, Hunter and Allie, and friend Mike Henry stayed up the night before the Tax Party making signs. One held by her young daughter exclaimed “Right-wing extremist” with an arrow pointing down. Another read, “I’m spending less. Government should too.” Diedre explained, “We’re protesting the taxes that are coming down the pike that will put our children in debt.” “We’re the silent majority, who never turn up,” joined Henry. “This our first protest. This is a free country, and I’m tired of being run over.” Organized by Mark West and Bryan Haddock, the party featured representatives from the Fair Tax movement, and local conservative electeds Rhonda Thurman, Hamilton County School Board, Matthew Bryant, recently-elected chair of the Hamilton County Republicans, and Robin Smith, chairman of the Tennessee Republican Party, spoke at the rally. Bryant read a collection of quotes from conservative leaders talking about taxes and fiscal policy and encouraged the crowed to respond, “We’ve had enough.” He continued, “We’re not all from one party or another today. There are probably a number of political parties represented here. We can join together and say, “We’ve had enough! We’re protesting against all politicians today.” Mark West took a seven minute break during the rally to encourage people to call their elected officials and register their complaints. While walking through the crowd, one woman was overheard calling Senator Saxby Chambliss and saying, “I’m very disappointed in you.” It seems not all the venom was aimed towards Democrats. Later, West urged protesters to look around and meet the people surrounding them. “Over the last few weeks, we’ve been told that we’re alone. That no one would go to a Tea Party. We’ve been called the fringe, nutjobs, extremists and even terrorists. Look around you. Are you alone? Do you see nutjobs or extremists?” Henry’s father also took a few minutes to speak, “Many children not even born yet are in debt. The minute that they’re born, they’re in debt $36,000.” He then referenced the TARP bill and exclaimed,“If it’s not worth taking the time to read. It’s not worth passing into law.” Over the course of three hours, more than 1,000 people expressed a clear message: They’re tired of the government expanding its own power and spending their tax dollars. They weren’t wealthy Republicans or high-power lobbyists, but average Chattanoogans who have worked hard in their careers and want to provide a solid future for their children and grandchildren. They didn’t show up on a chilly April afternoon to protect their greed, but turned out from fear and anger that the national debt will cripple the average taxpayer out of achieving the American dream.

Comments (9)

  1. Kate on April 16, 2009

    I'm glad they exercised their right to participate in such a protest, however, signs like "Socialism Kills" really got to me. Are they aware that Socialism was a working class movement? That it is not a concrete philosophy of fixed doctrine and program and therefore has not killed anyone? Application may have failed but has not, too, the application of Capitalism? Hasn't Capitalism "killed" as well, then?

  2. Bret on April 16, 2009

    People may be tired of government spending "our" money, but that's the way it works.

    If any of those folks have jobs they already know that Obama has already cut their taxes. Thank you, Mr. President.

  3. TFF on April 16, 2009

    Where were these concern trolls when the GOP pissed away MASSIVE budget surpluses and facilitated the creation of ever more wildly irresponsible investment vehicles and skyrocketing levels of borrowing to sustain paltry economic growth while the banks leveraged, privatized gains and publicized risk?

    Let me guess: using their homes as ATM machines, accumulating massive consumer debt, and systematically marginalizing dissent or voices calling for reform.

    This disjointed group of resentful misfits can shout all they want, but until they can cobble together a coherent, unified plan that can stand up to even basic scrutiny, they will be nothing but a mere mob.

  4. CosmoCon on April 16, 2009

    Bret, the measly $7 or $8 a week that I get a paycheck is a miniscule drop in the bucket compared to what the government is wasting on the stimulus and TARP.

    TFF, you're absolutely right. Conservatives allowed Bush to take us away from the party of fiscal conservativism and now we're feeling it in our pocketbooks. Please look at my post on the formation of the Tea Parties.

    We're trying to develop a coherent strategy and return to our roots, but the right has a lot to account for. Just this week DHS started using the Patriot Act against us. We're guilty (myself included) of fearing the mighty GOP and not telling President Bush no. I disliked his administration but didn't do enough to try to stop it.

  5. TFF on April 16, 2009

    CC-

    Never seen a so-called Conservative complain about a tax cut until your post.

    We truly live in interesting times.

    With regard to your criticism of Bush's TARP and the Obama stimulus, I'd be interested in hearing how you would have dealt with the banking crisis and the cratered private sector demand brought about by the credit tightness.

    Are you an advocate of cutting federal spending in a recession?

    With regard to DHS, you might want to look at some of the rhetoric coming from your side before you start playing the victim card. Here's a roundup from the last couple of days alone:

    1. A sitting GOP governor openly talking about secession
    2. Not, one, but two Fox News anchors openly agreeing with said governor.
    3. A GOP representative and potential candidate for the Illinois Senate seat held by Mr. Burris talking about how folks are “ready to shoot the people who raise taxes”.
    4. GOP Representative Michael McCaul openly making violent allusions to the current administration.

    I am the first to advocate a vocal and coherent loyal opposition, but your party has hitched itself to a deranged, intellectually bankrupt and potentially dangerous fringe.

  6. Kevin on April 16, 2009

    If everyone, nationwide, who attended these Tea Parties had taken 5 minutes to change their W-4 withholding status to "exempt" before leaving work that day, a tax revolt would be well under way.

  7. Bret on April 17, 2009

    Yeah, Kevin, that would work until they filed their 2009 taxes and had to come up with the money. Of course, many of them like June Griffin don't even work or pay any taxes.

    Now if everyone just decided not to file any more tax returns, that would be a real protest!

    The problem I see with this tea party thing is that there are no solutions offered. In fact, it isn't really clear exactly what is being protested. It's just a mish-mash of rebel-rousers, as if someone said, "Hey, let's go get some signs made up and go protest .... something."

  8. stephen42 on April 17, 2009

    The tea party is a great idea, to bad it was stained with partisian politics before it ever got started.
    Our government and every political party in our history has been guilty of wasteful spending for over 200 years. Why does anyone expect just because we have a new president that D.C.'s SOP will change.
    To the Democrats, Obama has done NOTHING but give our tax dollars to poorly run businesses.
    To the Republicans, Obama has done NOTHING that the republicans haven't been doing for years.

  9. Kevin on April 17, 2009

    stephen42- Agreed. Sean Hannity and FauxNews trying to co-opt a tax protest while complaining about spending is laughable, at best.

    Brett- Yes, had they changed their withholding status to exempt, refusing to file a return in 2010 would be the next logical step.

    I've heard nationwide attendance estimates as high as 6,000,000 (I don't know if that's by million-man march standards).

    I suspect 6,000,000 people, en masse, exempting themselves from withholding would result in congressmen stampeding to co-ponsor the Fair Tax (despite its problems, it is better than our current system, which is nothing more than a tool bureaucrats use to reward those who support them, punish those who oppose them, and redistribute wealth in a manner that benefits the incumbent).

    The attendees were a motley group, offering mixed messages of dissent, and seeming to lack organization. I suppose colonial America's tavern patrons were much the same in the early 1770s.
    Whether Tea Partiers are simply sunshine soldiers and summer patriots is yet to be determined, as the weather was pretty fair on Wednesday.

    Despite all that, it was a thing of beauty to see the 1st Amendment exercised, because, as we all know, rights, like muscles, if not exercised, will atrophy.

    As for me, I simply want to see the U.S. government compete in a fiscal version of The Biggest Loser.

Comments are closed.

Summary

Adrienne Royer shares her experiences at the Chattanooga Tea Party.

About the Author